# Tabata Amaral Challenges Senate's Multi-Million Dollar Smartphone Procurement Plan Federal deputy questions the legality and necessity of high-end device acquisitions for legislators. - **Source:** [Estadão](https://www.estadao.com.br) - **Published:** 2026-11-11 - **Topic:** [politics](https://brifing.si/c/politics) - **Original article:** - **On Brifing:** https://brifing.si/s/7078f26f-e1d2-420b-baf1-52cef254f2f6 ## Legal Challenge Initiated Deputy Tabata Amaral has formally requested the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) to suspend the Senate's procurement process for new smartphones. The challenge targets a contract estimated at R$ 6 million. Amaral argues that the acquisition of high-end devices violates the New Bidding Law, which prohibits purchasing luxury items for public administration. ## Procurement Details Revealed The Senate's tender includes 425 smartphones provided under a four-year loan agreement. This inventory features 95 iPhone 18 Pro units and 330 intermediate Android devices. The contract covers mobile services, modems, and chips, with a monthly cost of R$ 582.74 per line for iPhones and R$ 139.29 for the Android-based smartphones. ## Senate Leadership Defense Senate President Davi Alcolumbre defended the procurement, labeling criticism from Senator Cleitinho Azevedo as misinformation. Alcolumbre clarified that the devices are provided via a loan regime rather than direct purchase. He emphasized that usage is optional, stating that senators may decline the equipment just as they can refuse official vehicles or staff. ## Regulatory Compliance Concerns Amaral contends the edict fails to justify the specific brand requirements. The New Bidding Law mandates that public purchases meet common quality standards unless specific compatibility needs exist. She claims the Senate's own documentation admits the choice of high-end models is not driven by functional necessity, but rather by a desire for modernity. ## Operational Justification Cited The Senate maintains that the loan model offers operational and economic advantages over direct ownership. Officials argue that rapid technological obsolescence and the need for quick replacements in case of defects would otherwise incur significant maintenance costs. The contract stipulates that devices must be replaced every two years to ensure continued functionality. ## Broader Legislative Spending The controversy extends beyond the Senate, as Amaral also highlighted a similar procurement by the Chamber of Deputies. That body plans to spend over R$ 5.77 million on 604 tablets with 5G connectivity and 91 Wi-Fi models. These devices include high-end options like the iPad Pro 11, raising further questions regarding public spending. ## Discrepancies in Device Count Amaral questioned the specific quantity of Apple devices requested in the Senate tender. While the legislative house consists of 81 senators, the edict provides for between 75 and 95 units. The lack of clarity regarding which specific roles or departments are entitled to the high-end iPhone 18 Pro remains a point of contention. ## Future Implementation Timeline Despite the ongoing legal challenge and public criticism, the Senate intends to begin the service provision on February 1, 2027. The outcome now rests with the TCU, which must determine if the procurement aligns with the principles of economic efficiency and the legal restrictions against acquiring luxury goods for public officials. ## Sources covering this story - [Poder360 — Senate President Clarifies iPhone Procurement Policy Amid Public Criticism](https://www.poder360.com.br/poder-congresso/alcolumbre-diz-que-senadores-poderao-recusar-iphones/) - [Estadão — Tabata Amaral Challenges Senate's Multi-Million Dollar Smartphone Procurement](https://www.estadao.com.br/politica/tabata-amaral-aciona-tcu-para-suspender-licitacao-que-preve-95-iphones-para-o-senado-nprp/) - [G1 – Política — Senator Cleitinho Criticizes Six Million Real Senate Smartphone Tender](https://g1.globo.com/politica/blog/andreia-sadi/post/2026/11/12/cleitinho-celulares-senado.ghtml) --- _Summary written by Brifing from the original reporting. Copyright in the original article belongs to its publisher; read the full piece at the link above._