# Lula Allies Fear 'Waldir Pires Effect' Regarding Rafael Fonteles Potential appointment of Piauí governor to Finance Ministry sparks concerns over political abandonment. - **Source:** [Estadão](https://www.estadao.com.br) - **Published:** 2026-11-07 - **Topic:** [politics](https://brifing.si/c/politics) - **Original article:** - **On Brifing:** https://brifing.si/s/791ae411-b907-455f-ad1c-f21ad77eb98d ## Ministerial Speculation Risks Speculation surrounds the potential appointment of Piauí governor Rafael Fonteles to the Ministry of Finance. While Fonteles is a key figure within the PT, allies of President Lula worry that removing him from his state role could trigger a significant political backlash among his constituents who recently re-elected him with 70.90% of votes. ## The Waldir Pires Precedent Petista leaders are citing the 1986 case of Waldir Pires as a cautionary tale for Fonteles. Pires abandoned his governorship in Bahia to run as vice president on the Ulysses Guimarães ticket in 1989. This decision resulted in widespread voter frustration and left Pires without either the state government or the presidency. ## Electoral Consequences of Abandonment The 1989 presidential race, which followed the end of the military dictatorship, saw the Guimarães ticket finish in seventh place with only 4.73% of the vote. Fernando Collor ultimately won that election, defeating Lula. PT members fear that Fonteles could face a similar political fate if he leaves his mandate prematurely. ## Voter Frustration and Legitimacy Fonteles secured over 1.4 million votes in the first round of the Piauí election. Allies argue that leaving this position to serve in Brasília would be perceived as a betrayal of the electoral mandate. Such a move risks alienating the very base that provided him with a strong mandate for regional governance. ## The 'Indemissible' Minister Dilemma Within the Planalto Palace, there is a specific concern regarding the long-term stability of the Finance Ministry. Officials worry that appointing a high-profile governor like Fonteles would make him an 'indemissible' minister. This status would limit President Lula's flexibility to reorganize his cabinet if economic policies or political alliances shift later. ## Historical Context of Pires Waldir Pires held various roles, including Minister of Social Security, Defense, and head of the CGU during Lula's first term. Despite his long career, his 1989 decision remained a point of controversy. He later described the choice to leave Bahia as a personal sacrifice intended to prevent a perceived betrayal of the country. ## Political Vulnerability Concerns The core fear among Lula's inner circle is that Fonteles could end up with no political power base. If he resigns as governor and is subsequently replaced or removed from the Finance Ministry by the President, he would lose his influence in Piauí and his position in the federal government simultaneously. ## Strategic Decision Making The debate highlights the tension between national cabinet needs and regional political stability. For Fonteles, the path forward involves weighing the prestige of the Finance Ministry against the risk of losing his political capital in Piauí. The party remains divided on whether the potential gain justifies the significant electoral and reputational risk. ## Sources covering this story - https://www.estadao.com.br/politica/coluna-do-estadao/aliados-de-lula-temem-efeito-waldir-pires-se-fonteles-assumir-fazenda-entenda/ — --- _Summary written by Brifing from the original reporting. Copyright in the original article belongs to its publisher; read the full piece at the link above._