# Tension and Controversy Erupt During Domenica In Broadcast Alan Friedman's unexpected comments about Barbara d'Urso spark debate on Italian television. - **Source:** [Today.it](https://www.today.it) - **Published:** 2026-11-08 - **Topic:** [entertainment](https://brifing.si/c/entertainment) - **Original article:** - **On Brifing:** https://brifing.si/s/a8763686-eaa8-4b8a-bb4f-069d3da76465 ## Unexpected Live Comparison During the November 8 episode of Domenica In, guest Alan Friedman caused a moment of palpable tension. While discussing the show Ballando con le stelle, Friedman unexpectedly compared current judge Barbara d'Urso to her predecessor, Selvaggia Lucarelli. He stated that seeing d'Urso makes him miss Lucarelli's presence on the panel. ## Host Reaction to Conflict Mara Venier, the host of the program, reacted to the comment with a brief smile while looking at her phone. She quickly prompted Friedman to elaborate on his provocative statement. The atmosphere in the studio became visibly awkward as the guests navigated the sudden shift toward discussing the show's casting choices. ## Friedman's Critique of Style Friedman clarified his stance by describing Lucarelli as professionally sharp and critical, whereas he characterized d'Urso as being in a state of self-misunderstanding. He questioned whether the current format is the right environment for d'Urso, attempting to justify his preference for the former judge's specific brand of television personality. ## Panelist Perspectives on Performance Anna Pettinelli and Enzo Miccio supported Friedman's sentiment, suggesting that d'Urso appears unsettled and is not currently performing at her best. They noted that she carries the weight of past professional experiences into her new role, which seems to affect her overall demeanor and confidence during the live broadcasts. ## Defense of the Judge Rossella Erra stepped in to defend d'Urso, emphasizing that she has not replaced anyone in an unfair manner. Erra insisted that d'Urso remains calm and composed in her new role. Mara Venier also offered support, noting that her recent interview with d'Urso revealed a person who is currently very tranquil. ## Context of Casting Changes Selvaggia Lucarelli, who served as a judge for years, has transitioned to a role as an opinionist for Grande Fratello on Mediaset. Her absence from the current season of Ballando con le stelle remains a frequent topic of discussion among viewers and social media users, highlighting the impact of her departure. ## Broader Media Landscape Dynamics The incident reflects the ongoing fluidity of Italian television talent, where personalities frequently move between competing networks. Such public debates regarding casting choices are common in the industry, often serving to generate buzz for prime-time programs. The discussion concluded abruptly, with the panel moving on to other scheduled show segments. ## Significance of Television Debates This exchange underscores how personal opinions from guests can disrupt the planned flow of live television. While the moment caused temporary discomfort, it highlights the intense public interest in the casting dynamics of major variety shows. Such controversies often dominate social media discourse, keeping the programs relevant in the cultural conversation. ## Sources covering this story - https://www.today.it/tv/news/ballando-stelle/selvaggia-lucarelli-barbara-d-urso-domenica-in.html — --- _Summary written by Brifing from the original reporting. Copyright in the original article belongs to its publisher; read the full piece at the link above._